Category Archives: Book Review

The Broken Home- Translation by Lopa Banerjee



To retain the quintessential  essence of Gurudev’s work, is a herculean challenge.The native language is definitely the fulcrum of a writer’s work and translating it in a foreign language sometimes leads to destruction of balance between thoughts, imagery, language and off course the beauty of the prose in consideration. To quote noted lyricist Gulzar: “Translation is not only about displaying a meaning in another language. A language carries a complete culture. The culture of its vocabulary needs to be translated. If readers can’t feel the shades of the character and the links of the scene, it hasn’t been  translated properly.”

Lopa Banerjee’s translation of Tagore’s famous novella  ”The Broken Nest”  is a commendable attempt to lay bare to the world -Tagore’s compassionate and lyrical portrayal of the angst of an intelligent beautiful woman Charu trying to break free of ennui by dabbling into the imaginary world of prose and poetry. In her flights of fantasy Charu is ably supported by her brother-in-law Amal. The tapestry of their relationship is permeated by mutual respect, love for words, yearning for a beautiful world. It is foolhardy to give a name to their relationship or inanely name it as attraction or passion. Both of them nurture each other and this draws their soul together. Bhupati, Charu’s husband in his attempt to enlighten the world through his newspaper venture fails to recognize Charu’s need for companionship- this vacuity is fulfilled by Amal till probably it becomes too much for Amal to handle and Amal resolves to set sail to foreign shores to break free from the fetters of a relationship that the myopic world would label as illicit. It never probably occurred to Bhupati to fuel his hearth lamp so that it could shine more luminously- the  crack in his hearth was beyond Bhupati’s comprehension till it was too late.

Banerjee, through her skilled use of language deftly translates Tagore’s portrayal of the New Woman (nabeena), struggling to break free from the confined space of andar mahal/antahpur (inner domain) in the patriarchal society of pre-colonial Bengal. The end of the nineteenth century witnessed the advent of the New Woman -educated in literature yet forced to remain within the confines of the inner domains which led to clash of the New Woman with  the traditional woman practicing old ways of life. Banerjee, deftly etches such dramatic turmoil between Charu and Manda. The trials and tribulations of each persona of this Tagore novella has been beautifully brought out in Banerjee’s translated work. She has arguably emerged as a translator par excellence.

As a reader I was spellbound by the atmosphere created by Banerjee of a bygone era- an era that sowed the seeds of future promise – the struggles that women of Bengal undertook during those times has enabled women like me to spend a considerable portion of childhood free of any dogmatic shackles in my Bengal. Thank you Lopa Banerjee for reminding me of the history of my city.

Kudos Lopa Banerjee and looking forward to many more.

© Dr. Paromita Mukherjee Ojha, 2018




Ashtavakra and Other Poems by Vineetha Mekkoth

Ashtavakra and Other Poems

 Authored By: Vineetha Mekkoth

Publisher:  Authorspress

ISBN-13: 9789386722522

Year of Publication: 2017


Some poems are read in a frenzied haste to imbibe the superficial essence….Some are read in tranquility at a leisurely pace to immerse your soul in the pleasurable experience that the poet offers through His/Her vision/ruminations on the varied kaleidoscope that we mortals simply call ‘Human Life’. Vineetha Mekkoth’s  ‘Ashtavakra and Other Poems’ entranced me enough to commence on this poetic journey together where I confidently let her hold my hand and let her imagination take me to that promised land of colour and sweet nothings( Extract from the poem –Place your hand in mine, dear).

Like a brimming, playful river that charts its own course with each bend opening new vistas of undulated, virgin land, each poem in this collection posits a new facet of the poet’s unbridled imagination and concern for human life and travesties of modern so called educated society. The lines from the very first poem of this collection -‘Man – I am a woman……You can bruise me, you can batter me but my spirit will remain forever free’(From One to Another)…touched a deep chord within me as it so vividly depicted the plight of women worldwide who are subjugated, humiliated,imprisoned, fettered by the shackles of patriarchy. The angst of human soul caught in the humdrum of mundane life is brought out beautifully in another poem called ‘Paper Boat Dreams‘- where the imprisoned soul takes a decision finally – ‘ I will let me go because I am tired of being me’.

Another  noteworthy poem is Ashtavakra where myth and reality is blended beautifully and the angst of modern life that has suffocated and paralyzed humaneness in humanity is highlighted with acute poignancy. The beautiful carefree days of yore spent in grandma’s lap listening to the songs of summer – a summer that can never return in this modern materialistic age of ours is brought out in the poem ‘Granma’s Summer‘.

Each poem in this collection made me trudge willingly with the poet, crossing so many rivulets of emotions, pushing through bush and briar(Moon World) to finally reach the end of this wonderful poetic offering where my soul seeped in the vivid imagery etched by the poet yearned for more.

I eagerly look forward  to Vineetha Mekoth’s  next poetic offering…. I am taking the liberty to amend two lines from her Roseate Sonnet- In Our Hands

What promises does the next volume hold?

What bright poetic vision waits to unfold?

A must read for all who value life in all its myriad forms….Kudos Vineetha Mekkoth!!!!




The Quiet Type by Summer Prescott

A book that persuades the reader to read it in one go till the very end…..every character well etched..the central character and her macabre pursuit of a specific form of art sends chills down the readers soul…one is forced to think about one’s neighbours and whether the calm on the surface is the prelude of some storm brewing …the book is also a reminder to parents to nurture their children by providing them with the right sort of environment and paying attention to their emotional needs.. After all, we humans are a product of nature and nurture isn”t it??

Riders to the Sea

At the beginning of the play the readers are told the play is set in a cottage situated on an island off the west of Ireland. The title Riders to the Sea becomes relevant when the play opens with Nora, one of the characters in the play tells her sister Cathleen that she has brought clothes of a drowned man given to her by the young priest for identification since their brother Michael had been missing and was suspected to have been drowned in the sea. From the beginning itself the premonition of death and destruction looms large in the play. The sea becomes a powerful symbol of both preserver and destroyer of life. The play revolves around the sea. In the beginning the suspense was whether the sea would return the body of Michael and towards the end the suspense was whether the last remaining son Bartley would also be engulfed by the sea. Maurya poignantly describes the havoc wreaked by the sea on her family and her stoic resignation at the cruel blows of fate that took away all her sons and her husband whenever they rode to the sea to eke out a livelihood. The realistic language used in the play strengthens the idea that such circumstances do take place in human life and we have to accept the inevitability of fate.


The entire play is set in a poor fisherman’s cottage. The story is about a family of four surviving members. Maurya, the matriarch had already lost four of her sons and husband in the sea. When the play opens she feared her fifth son Michael also to be drowned however his body was yet to be found. Maurya had already begun lamenting for nine days and was waiting for Michael’s body to be washed ashore. The last surviving son, Bartley had already procured white boards for his brother Michael’s coffin. In the mean time Bartley announces his intention to go to the Galway Fair to sell horses. Maurya desperately tries to stop him from venturing into this perilous journey as she has a premonition that Bartley too would never return home from this journey. Maurya follows Bartley after he leaves so that she can give him a cake and her blessings but on the way she has a nerve wrecking vision of Michael following Bartley. Maurya is convinced that she would never see Bartley alive anymore and incidentally her vision comes true with the arrival of Bartley’s dead body. J.M Synge has masterfully created this well-knit play by not allowing any digressions in the plot and this has helped build the intensity of the plot. An overwhelming foreboding of doom and destruction is build up right from the opening of the play. All past tragedies are skillfully reported by the characters to help lead the play to its conclusion and the dramatic unity of time and place is adhered to by restricting the action of the entire play to a cottage and in one day.

This one act play encompasses the essence of the constant struggle of the island people against the tumultuous sea and their stoic acceptance of their fates sealed by the elements of nature.

The language used in the play is realistic and is similar to the language used by the local people of the Irish islands. Many lines are very poetic as seen in the following lines said by Maurya: “May the Almighty God have mercy…everyone left living in the world“. These lines have a stark poignant beauty and an acceptance of the inevitable cycle of life and death. The recurring use of words and expressions ‘black night’, ‘black cliff’, ‘the pig with black feet‘ etc creates an atmosphere of doom and apprehension. There is a wondrous beauty in the speech of every character in this play. Synge has penned Maurya’s final lines with profound wisdom imbued with pathos: “Michael has a clean burial in the far north, by the grace of the Almighty God. Bartley will have a fine coffin out of the white boards, and a deep grave surely. What more can we want than that? No man at all can be living for ever, and we must be satisfied.

This and other poetical and rhetorical lines that permeate this play highlight the clam that emerges in human mind after a great emotional upheaval. This play has a timeless appeal because of realistic depiction of human tragedies, resilience and acceptance. Thus Synge’s “Riders to the Sea” has been termed as one of the greatest modern tragedy in English. Riders to the sea is a realistic play as Synge has tried to present a slice of life in the islands; he has tried to incorporate Irish folklore in the play to depict human failure and helplessness in controlling the elements of the sea. The play revolves around the lives of few characters who are suffering after losing their members of the family who tried to eke out a living by venturing into the sea. This tragedy represents the pain of millions of islanders who continuously lose their dear ones to the powerful sea. The stage directions are also very vivid and elaborate so that any director while creating the set of the play would be able to visualize and create an exact replica of the writer’s vision if the play is enacted on the stage and the audience would also be able to identify with what they would be viewing on the stage.


Narendra Jadhav’s Outcaste as a Dalit text


The word “caste” has its roots in the Latin word ‘castus,’ which means pure or chaste. The caste system is often defined in an idealized manner as constituting four distinct social groups, also known as varnas. The varnas are ranked in hierarchical relation to each other with Brahmins (priests and teachers) at the apex of the social order, followed by Kshatriyas (rulers and warriors), Vaishyas (merchants and farmers), and Shudras (workers and craftspeople), who are at the bottom tiers of the caste pyramid. In addition to these four caste groups, there is another distinct social group of people in the Indian society who, on account of their polluting nature, are regarded as socially unworthy to be included in the caste or varna system. They are a people without any caste identity and hence are the outcastes of the Indian society. Their “outcaste” status does not imply that they constitute a separate society; they are, in many aspects of life very much an integral part of the Indian society. While the outcastes are not part of the caste system, their lives are inextricably tied to caste system. There is little or no caste mobility for the outcastes of the Indian society. They are almost always ranked at the bottom of Indian society. Throughout the known history of the caste system, the outcastes of the Indian society have been called by a variety of pejorative terms such as Chandalas (dirty), Panchamas (the fifth caste) Avarnas (without caste). Untouchables, Depressed classes (under British rule) and Harijans (God’s children, Gandhi) are terms used before the word ‘Dalit’ gained widespread appeal among the caste oppressed communities to assert their selfhood and identity. The term was first used in the nineteenth century by a Marathi social reformer and revolutionary Mahatma Jyotirao Phule to “describe the outcastes and untouchables as the oppressed and broken victims of [the] caste-ridden society”. The term gained mainstream appeal during the 1970s Dalit Panther Movement of Maharashtra where it was used as a constant reminder of their age-old oppression, denoting both their state of deprivation and the people who are oppressed.

The institution of the caste system is a complex and multifaceted exploitative cultural system that for thousands of years has been the primary source of oppression of Dalit communities in India. The caste system is not only a form of socio-cultural exploitation but also a form of group identity for Dalit communities. As an outcaste community, the Dalits in India endure a variety of prohibitions, discriminations, disabilities and segregations imposed on them by the dominant caste groups. The most pronounced form of segregation is the geographical seclusion of their residential areas from mainstream society.

The Dalits constitute a large but significantly distinct population of India whose cultural experiences are profoundly marked by discrimination and oppression based on caste. Even though they are not a homogenous social category, they are demarcated from the rest of the society by a fault line that runs through the Indian society. This fault line is the notion of ritual purity and pollution that is the ideological base to the structural reality of the caste system, a unique but fundamental organizing principle of Indian society that is closely identified with the orthodox version of Hinduism. With no legitimate place in the caste order and deemed as ritually polluted people by the caste Hindu community, Dalits endure the most inhumane forms of oppression and exploitation.

“Dalit literature is one which acquaints people with the caste system and untouchability in India, it’s appalling nature and its system of exploitation. In other words, Dalit is not a caste but a realization and is related to the experiences, joys and sorrows, and struggles of those in the lowest stratum of society. It matures with a sociological point of view and is related to the principles of negativity, rebellion and loyalty to science, thus finally ending as revolutionary.

Dalit life writing is a genre of Indian texts that emerged first in regional languages, and, in the1990s, in English; the genre situates personal and collective suffering within a larger discourse of human rights. “Dalit,” derived from the Marathi—the predominant language of Maharashtra state—literally means “of the earth” and “that which has been ground down” and now signifies socially oppressed caste groups and tribals. Ironically, these marginalized Dalit peoples constitute a large segment of the population, and have been forced to mobilize themselves in order to fight for rights and justice in postcolonial India. Dalit writing is revolutionary in its aims; the destruction of the caste system and the establishment of equality in the social and political spheres. Dalit critics and writers have raised a number of critical questions about Indian literature and Indian literary history. Alok Mukherjee, a literary theorist and a human rights activist, aptly sumps up the significance of Dalit writing, “Indian literary history and theory as well as the teaching of Indian literatures are spectacularly silent about Dalit literature. Yet, dalit cultural and critical productions make a significant critical intervention in the thinking and writing about Indian society, history, culture and literature.”
He identifies two of the important functions of Dalit writing. Firstly, Dalit writing attempts to deconstruct ‘the dominant, casteiest constructions of India identity’ and secondly’ it constructs a distinct Dalit identity.’ Dalit writing presents a dalit centric view of life and constructs Dalit identity in relation to Colonial identity and Indian identity.

The reading and writing of Dalit literature is mostly passionately autobiographical involving the search for the self or identity. Each individual writer makes it her/his privilege to write the stories of their community in the stories of their own. By means of writing these writers break the silence of Dalit community. They as an individual writer articulated or gave voice to Dalit experience which until now was hidden, repressed and secreted. These writings are not just about finding voice but also about finding voice but also about revelation of the most inner life of a community in a public or a kind of confession or a scandal. Their task as a writer is to transform voice and silence into literary tropes. The search is not merely sociological one as a search for Dalit community, culture and so on, but it is a philosophical aesthetic search for Dalitness.

Narendra Jadhav is a well-known economist, public speaker and a social worker. He has also served many international assignments with IMF. Outcaste: A Memoir is an adaptation by Narendra Jadhav, from his own Marathi best-seller Amcha Bap Aan Amhi (Our Father and Us). The novel is a multi-layered personalized saga of the social metamorphosis of Dalits in India. At one level, it is a loving tribute from a son to his father. At another, it gives an intelligent appraisal of the caste system in India and traces the story of the awakening of Dalits traversing three generations. At still another level, it is reflective of the aspirations of millions of Dalits in India. The novel forces us to acknowledge the inhumanity and injustice of a social order that treats humans worse than animals. Outcaste captures the life of India’s villages and Bombay’s slums with an anthropologist’s precision and a novelist’s humanity. The story begins in the 1930s when Damu, the protagonist of the story, is continuously addressed as “Mahar” in his ancestral village in Western Maharashtra where caste determined one’s destiny. Damu, refused to comply with the conventional casteist codes prescribed by society and religion.

The politically conscious of untouchables began to feel that they were being used by caste Hindu leaders and the Congress party. Thus, under Ambedkar’s leadership and initiative the untouchables began to call themselves ‘Dalits’ they aspired to take the leadership of anti-caste movements into their fold without letting either Hinduism or the Congress party meddle with their affairs. This process of shifting the leadership was easier said than done; so Ambedkar followed a strategy of initiating the Dalits into politics and activism through education and awareness. The followers were, of course, driven by passion and fervour for revolution but they also knew they were doing and why unlike the communist, Ambedkar followed a more or less pacifist approach by giving the Dalits time and patience to digest the radical ideas.

Influenced by Dr. Ambedkar’s teachings, Damu stood against the Police and the caste system. Damu was not born a leader, nor did he ever become one. But he had one exception—he chose to rebel against the prevailing caste system and create his own destiny. An intelligent man, with no formal education, he worked hard to be allowed to live with dignity. In his Author’s note, Jadhav, describes Damu as, “Damu was not a leader…but he refused to define himself by circumstances and aimed at shaping his own destiny.” or, “Damu had no formal education …yet he steered his children to educational heights and inculcated in them the spirit of excellence.”, or “Damu was not a guru…but he taught his children to believe in themselves and retain human dignity.”, or “Damu was often humbled. Yet he maintained, goats are special offerings, not lions” or “Damu was an ordinary man, they said …..but he did an extraordinary thing; he stood up against the tyranny of the caste system”. (pp. xi-xii).

‘Outcaste’ is a compelling story of a Dalit family and their subsequent transformation and the novel also chronicle Dalit history. Ambedkar’s philosophy, a major influence on Damu, has been brought in extensively in the novel but without disturbing the thread of the tale. Unlike the accounts given by sociologists and political scientist, the book has meticulously kept track of the common man’s response to each political or social development. It hardly tries to theorize or profess any ideology directly but it shows how even an illiterate like Damu was able to imbibe the essence of Ambedkarism and the rationale behind conversion. Gandhiji and Babasaheb were two towering personalities who could understand the pulse of India through both belonged to different schools of thought. The political and ideological conflict between the two was a much talked about issue in independent India. While Gandhiji offered sympathy and support Ambedkar exhorted them to rise and shine wherever they are. The Gandhi-Babasaheb conflict strikes the readers as the central event happening in the background of Damu’s quest for identity. Ambedkar wanted to break away from the prevailing hegemonic religious and political system which hardly gave a platform for the Dalits to voice themselves. The Dalits chose to support Babasaheb because they could relate to him better than anyone else in the Indian political scenario. Ambedkar felt that Untouchables have to fight their own battle and if others are concerned about them then such a concern has to be expressed in helping them to fight rather than prescribing solutions to them’.

Written in the first person, at times from the perspective of Narendra Jadhavs parents, Damu and Sonu, and at other times from his own the book traces the extraordinary voyage of Damu from a small village at Ozar in Maharashtra to the city of Mumbai to escape persecution. It was a journey that brought back his dignity and “touchability”. In the city, he earned respect in various jobs, despite being a low-caste and an illiterate. The caste differences are not so rigid in the cities and urban areas as they in the villages and suburbs. Right at the beginning Damu acknowledges that ‘the city had brought touch ability to his life’ (pp. 6).While people in the village kept him and his community at bay even while offering them food, the Gorasaheb in the city treated him like a human being with respect. He even doubted whether the Saheb knew that he was an untouchable (pp. 92). It was life in Mumbai which made him aware of his right to existence as a dignified being and introduced him to Babasaheb’s movement.

His uncompromising spirit inspired his wife who realized that their emancipation could be possible only through the pursuit of academic excellence. Outcaste is also the story of Sonabai, the author’s mother. Her innocence as a pre-pubescent bride and horrified reluctance to give up her old and trusted gods for the unknown Buddha are instances of an ordinary Dalit woman’s experiences. In the book, Sonu’s story alternates with that of Damu’s. Damu is one of the few assertive, independent Dalit characters in Indian writing in English. In the opening pages of Outcaste, the readers read Damu doing his yeskar duties (village duties to Mahars) in his native village, Ozar. Damu is forced to run in front of the Mamledar, senior revenue official, announcing his arrival. Later, Damu is asked to guard the dead body of a woman found floating in the well. He was not allowed to go home to inform his wife and also to have his food. He was abused, insulted and forced to stay near the well the entire night. The next morning Fauzdar (a police officer) arrived and asked Damu to get into the well to draw the corpse out. Damu refused to do so under the pretext that he was not supposed to touch the dead body of an upper caste woman. The author declares: “The caste system is so deeply ingrained that change can, at best, be cosmetic. The caste system was disposed by God and not by mortals. It has such a powerful sanction behind it that no laws, no reform movements, and no revolutions will ever change it completely.” Damu was beaten up by the Fauzdar for refusing to obey his orders. He was stubborn and determined. He speaks out, “…Inspite of these inhuman traditions, I am not going to abide by such traditions. I am a man of dignity and I will not go from house to house begging for Baluta. What are all of you going to do? Kill me?”.(pp.10)

Change, however, does take place, in Damu’s life. He decides to leave his village that very night. He runs away along with his wife Sonu to Mumbai, “Together, they started walking towards freedom”. In Mumbai Damu struggled hard, as the author narrates, to survive through the Great depression in the 1930s. He worked in the Railways, the Port Trust and some textile mills to earn his living in Mumbai. Inspired by Ambedkar’s call for Dalit emancipation, Damu participated in Dalit movement. He actively involved himself in the Nasik Temple Entry Movement in 1930, in Mahad Satyagraha in 1927, in the Buddhist conversion movement in 1956, Ambedkar’s funeral procession and other activities of the Dalits. Babasaheb Ambedkar’s teachings have a profound effect on Damu and Sonu and they begin to develop a sense of self—“Truly, we sensed a change in the way we carried ourselves. We proudly proclaimed ourselves Dalits, with our chin up, and we looked everyone in the eye. We began to lose our former servility, associated with being born in low caste”. They inculcated in their children an ambition to succeed in life through education and hard work. Damu refused to be cowed down by all the odds in his life. He always declared himself as the master of his own will. Throughout the narrative runs the slogan coined by Dr. Ambedkar “Educate, Unite and Agitate”. Damu and his wife educate their children to the best of their abilities. He even tried to educate his wife Sonu, something that was unheard of in those times. Fortunately, the children all fulfil his aspirations and rise to high positions in their chosen careers, a great triumph for a man who has devoted his life to bettering their prospects.

Outcaste is more than a mere personal account of the caste divide in India. It examines the Dalit awakening spearheaded by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, the Independence movement, the Civil Disobedience Movement, Gandhiji’s relation with Ambedkar, the mass conversion of Dalits to Buddhism in 1956, and caste in its current reality. One can find Ambedkar’s call for the Dalits to “Educate, Unite and Agitate” as a recurrent theme in the book. Outcaste is the first book to portray Ambedkar as a character in its story. There is also a long note at the end of Outcaste on untouchability, the caste system and Dr. Ambedkar. Dr. Jadhav has wisely retained many Marathi words in the text, thus retaining the essence of the story intact. Personal anecdotes keep the book lively and easily readable. The book ends with a note of self-realization that in modern India dignity rests in the minds and hearts of people, and that archaic prejudices do not really matter. ‘Outcaste’ thus gives an interpretation of caste, which is astonishingly different and enlightening. This remarkable book achieves something altogether unprecedented: it gives voice to India’s voiceless. Jadhav tells the awe-inspiring story of his family’s struggle for equality and justice in India. While most Dalits had accepted their lowly position as fate, Jadhav’s father rebelled against the oppressive caste system and fought against all odds to forge for his children a destiny that was never ordained. Based on his father’s diaries and family stories, Jadhav has written the triumphant story of his parents — their great love, unwavering courage, and eventual victory in the struggle to free themselves and their children from the caste system. Jadhav vividly brings his parents’ world to light and unflinchingly documents the life of untouchables — the hunger, the cruel humiliations, the perpetual fear and brutal abuse. Compelling and deeply compassionate, “Outcaste” is a son’s tribute to his parents, an illuminating chronicle of one of the most important moments in Indian history, and an eye-opening work of nonfiction that gives readers access and insight into the lives of India’s 165 million Dalits, whose struggle for equality continues even today.

In this Memoir, the author examines the issues, which are so deep and penetrating in a manner, which is poignant. From one angle, it is an attack on the social structure of Hindu society. If this novel is studied in another angle, it is a call made to unite all the oppressed and humiliated people to empower themselves by devoting themselves to education and finally to stand as one nation of brotherhood to fight against tyranny, subjugation, slavery, oppression. The book ends with a self-realization that obsolete prejudices do not matter if human beings retain their self-dignity.

Without you by Preethi Venugopala

Well the name Ananya has become a household name, post Chetan Bhagat’s -Two States..So when I picked up this book I was a little skeptical. However, Preethi managed adeptly to keep my interest engaged with this sweet love story of Ananya and Arjun where they bravely trudge along the path that was never laid with roses for them. The backdrop of the novel is essentially Indian where every mother manages to find faults with the girl that their son chooses as his life partner. Preethi however introduces a new twist in the form of Colonel R.S.Nair who manages to change the course of this about to be doomed love story of Ananya and Arjun . The lovers manage to find their happily ever after and the readers also close the book with a happy smile. Great job Preethi!!

Iam16Icanrape by Kirtida Gautam

The premise of this book is as hardhitting as the title. The in-depth psychological analysis presented by the author is praise worthy. She raises a pertinent question about the Juvenile law prevalent in Indian legal system which due to its loopholes is misused by juveniles with criminal bent of mind. Like Rudransh Kashyap we need to wake up from our slumber as a progressive society and ensure adequate punishment of heinous crimes like rape. We cannot afford to shrug our shoulders anymore and let criminals walk scot-free. Kudos to the author for writing emphatically on a sensitive legal issue.
P.S. there are few typos/grammatical errors in the kindle manuscript which needs to be looked into…